“You don’t know me? Does that mean you’d go so far as to call me a stranger?”
She lets out an exasperated sigh, but I can tell by the frantic clutching of her fingers around the spiral that she’s not just frustrated. She’s downright terrified.
“Listen.” I take hold of her shoulders, stilling her nervous movements and forcing her to look at me. “You don’t have to tell me anything you don’t want to. And I promise I won’t look at your list again. I swear, okay? And I won’t tell Dylan or anyone else about it. But I want you to swear that whenever it’s something you don’t have to do alone or something you shouldn’t do alone . . . you’ll call me. I sing a mean karaoke, and I pull all-nighters all the time, and I—”
“Okay.”
I pause, letting my arms trail down from her shoulders to her elbows.
“Okay?”
I lean a little closer, pitching my mouth closer to hers. “Does that mean I can be your strange—”
She covers my lips with her hand, cutting off my words, and with that familiar proud tilt of her chin she says, “The list says to kiss a stranger. Not be kissed by one.”
And with that she pulls out of my arms and starts toward the pool, her hips swaying to the heavy pounding of my heart.
Chapter 9
Nell’s To-Do List
• Normal College Thing #12: Go skinny-dipping.
I keep my head held high and my back straight the whole way over to the pool.
But inside?
I am an equation with too many missing variables. My heart is doing things that biologically it should not be able to do. Or at least it feels that way. And my nerves begin to bleed through as I try with shaky hands to undo the childproof lock on the fence around the pool.
The pool where I am trespassing.
Where I am breaking the law.
And where I will presumably be wearing far less clothing in a matter of minutes if I do actually go through this.
Just breathe, Antonella. The more you breathe, the less panicked you’ll feel.
It’s all biology. Hormones and neurons and impulses. This is a biological response to an intimidating situation. I have nothing to fear here. My brain just thinks I do.
While I’m still struggling with the lock, Torres’s hands settle over the top of mine, halting my movements. He’s directly behind me, one arm on either side, effectively surrounding me with his skin and heat and scent.
“Relax,” he says in my ear, but if anything that just shatters the smidgen of control I’d managed to wrangle back from my panic. My shoulders tense, rising up closer to my ears, and I squeeze my eyes shut.
“I can’t,” I admit, my voice quiet. “You . . . intimidate me.”
“Why?”
“Because . . .”
“Because you like me. Even though I’m flashy and shameless. Even though I’m too concerned with how other people see me, and I’m like a puppet who doesn’t realize his strings are being pulled?”
I flinch at the reminder of what I said at that Frisbee game. He’d been so close and so appealing, and I’d lashed out with my most ruthless honesty so that he’d give me some space to breathe, to think.
I twist, looking over my shoulder at him, and my back comes into contact with his chest.
“I’m sorry. I shouldn’t have said that.”
He doesn’t look angry. His face is relaxed and easy, but he’s so good at putting on a show that could just be what he wants me to see.
“Don’t be. I’m just reminding you why you have no need to be embarrassed in front of me. You said we were complete opposites. That you don’t care what people think. So don’t start now. But if you’re too nervous, just say the word, and I’ll take us back to the party. Or I’ll go back to the party and leave you here to check this item off your list alone.”
I swallow. I don’t want to be alone. But I’m not sure I’m brave enough to do this with him either.
“Will you go first?” I ask.
He stills behind me, and his jaw clenches. I watch his neck work as he swallows, and I wonder what he’s thinking. His voice is deeper, almost hoarse, when he says, “Sure. I can do that.”
He pries my hands off the lock, and in a move that sends shock waves across my skin, he places a casual kiss on my fingers before releasing them.
All of a sudden I feel that same suffocating sensation that made me lash out at him with harsh words, but this time it makes me want to lash out in a different way. I want to place my hand on the sharp edge of his jaw and turn his face toward me. I want to bring my mouth to his and find out just how hot the heat between us can get.
But this time I control the impulse. I push it down, try to temper it with logic, but for every reason I think of why I shouldn’t kiss him, I think of another why I should.
With a victorious “Got it,” he undoes the latch and pulls the metal rod that the canvas fencing is attached to out of a divot in the ground. He folds the heavy fabric back, letting it rest on another part of the fence, and gestures at the pool.
“After you, my lady.”
There are only a few feet of concrete between the fencing and the water, so I step in and to the left, and he follows. The water is clear and still, glowing from the reflection of the moon.
“Me first?” Torres asks.
He’s already almost naked. All he has to do is slip off that loincloth and anything he has underneath it, and he’s done. Before I even give him an answer, he hooks his thumb under the band of his costume, and begins pushing it down his hips.
I gulp in air, and order myself to look away, but I can’t. I just can’t. Luckily, he’s wearing a pair of tight, black shorts beneath, and I’m able to finally pull my gaze away while he’s still covered. I hear him lay the loincloth over the fence in front of him, and I turn farther away, lest I be tempted to look back again.