Nolan grinned. “Are you sure?”
“Positive. I will take her ass for the first time.”
“You’ve always been an ass man,” Nolan remarked, then stripped his shirt and pants, tossing the clothing and feasting his gaze on her nakedness. His grin turned decidedly feral and Penny shivered. He palmed his cock and hefted the thick length. Penny wasn’t sure that large thing was going to fit inside her body. Fear of the unknown dampened her wild arousal but Nolan didn’t give her the chance to think too long. “On your knees, beautiful,” he instructed softly but firmly. She sank to the floor. His cock bobbed in front of her. The blunt head that sprang from a trimmed bed of hair was thick and mushroom-shaped and he smelled spicy and musky. She’d never smelled anything so arousing before. She wanted to bury her face in the crinkly hairs of his groin and nuzzle the thick length. She didn’t need to be told what to do next and simply went on instinct, sucking the big head into her mouth, marveling at the silken steel as it slid between her lips, growing harder as she sucked and lavished all the attention she could manage with her inexperience. Where she lacked in experience or technique, she tried to make up for with enthusiasm and judging by the way Nolan groaned with each suck and lick of her tongue, he appreciated her efforts. “God, she’s a fucking natural at sucking cock,” Nolan gasped, threading his fingers through her hair. “Yess,” he moaned, thrusting his hips against her face as she sucked harder and faster. The head of his cock banged against the back of her throat and she reached up to cup the twin soft sacs bouncing against her chin. A thin rivulet of saliva escaped her mouth and dribbled from the corners of her lips. She gripped his ass cheeks, drawing him closer, holding onto him as if for dear life, loving the sounds of his pleasure as he fucked her face with his thick cock.
Suddenly, another cock appeared and she eagerly accepted Vince’s member into her mouth while continuing to rub and stroke Nolan’s cock while she serviced Vince. She felt gloriously dirty and experienced as she played and sucked at both men. She glanced up at them and saw their eyes closed and their mouths hanging slightly open as they enjoyed her touch. But suddenly Nolan gently pulled away with a sigh and said, “Suck off my brother, darling girl. I wish to watch you take his cock down your throat before I fuck you senseless.”
He collapsed on the sofa, his glistening cock slapping against his thigh as he settled in to watch and she since she wanted to please them both, she returned to Vince’s cock in earnest. It wasn’t long before Vince’s groans changed with the tempo of his thrusts. Soon he was ramming his cock down her throat and fucking her face as he would her pussy. She was spiraling with insane pleasure knowing that she was driving him mad with desire. “That’s it, baby,” he grunted, his voice a tight growl. “I’m going to cum!”
She braced herself and seconds later her mouth was filled with warm salty fluid that shot down her throat in hurtling jets that matched each thrust against her face. She gulped the thick liquid, though at first it was startling but she eagerly took every drop. Vince’s spent cock slipped from her mouth and she surreptitiously wiped away the spit and sank back on her heels, waiting for what came next. Vince stumbled to the sofa and fell onto the leather with a heavy but satisfied grunt. “Holy shit, I’ve never cum so hard. Baby girl, you’re something else,” he praised her breathlessly. She couldn’t help her pleased grin at the compliment. It wasn’t something she could brag about outside of these walls but still, she’d take it. Vince looked to Nolan who was slowly palming his cock, keeping it hard and ready. “She deserves your tongue before you take her cherry. Trust me, she’s earned it.”
“Gladly,” Nolan said, moving from the sofa like a cat sliding from its perch. His muscles bunched and coiled beneath his skin and before she knew it, she was on her back with Nolan above her. His ash-blonde hair framed his gorgeous face and for a moment, Penny could only stare at the picture of male beauty poised above her. “Tell me, have you ever had a tongue playing with your clit?” he asked softly, the hard length of his cock pressing against her soft belly. At the awed shake of her head, he grinned and simply moved down her body, pausing to tongue the wide bowl of her navel before pushing her thighs apart to gaze down at her pink folds. Penny blushed at being so openly studied but she liked the way his eyes darkened with lust when he buried his face between her legs. She nearly twisted in on herself with the first exploratory flick of his tongue against her swollen little clit hidden between her slick folds. His wiggling tongue found and played with the hot button until she was writhing, begging for something that she could only dream of. Nothing in her fantasies had ever felt so good, so dirty. Something tingled deep inside her, building like a giant wave ready to crash to the shore. She struggled against its power, a bit frightened by the intensity but Nolan wouldn’t let her back off and mercilessly pushed her to that ledge. Her thighs began to quake and every muscle tensed as a riot of pleasure exploded inside her body. “Ohhhh,” she cried, thrashing her head from side to side as she was buffeted by the pleasure radiating from her clit and spreading across her nerve endings. Nolan lifted his head to smile knowingly and she blushed furiously. She covered her face with her hands as she tried to recover but Nolan wouldn’t let her.
He rose above her and firmly pulled her hands free. “I want to see every emotion as it travels across your face, especially after I’ve made you cum. Understand?”
She nodded but admitted, “I’m embarrassed.”
“Why?” he asked.
“Because I sounded like an animal,” she answered, unable to hide her awkwardness at the intimacies between them. His cock was still hard and ready, nudging at her damp thighs and small pulses of pleasure were still thrumming through her body.
His gracious smile did funny things to her insides as he said, “Darling, fucking is primal and raw. At its core, sex is all about returning to our most primitive selves. And the sounds you make when you cum are lovely. Now,” he said, his gaze darkening. “Time to pluck that sweet cherry.” She shuddered and nodded. Nolan regarded her with that intense stare, devouring her with his eyes. He bent down to take her mouth roughly. He smelled of her musk and it was intoxicating. His tongue tangled with hers almost savagely, fucking her with his tongue as thoroughly as Vince had fucked her mouth and she was nearly breathless with need and desire, twisting beneath Nolan as he pressed his cock against her. She opened her legs and the blunt head of Nolan’s hard length butted against her soft, slick folds. He gently bent her knees and pressed them to her chest, opening her further and leaving her vulnerable to his gaze. Her gaze shifted away, too shy to watch as Nolan prepared to breach her virgin walls. She wanted this — desperately — but her head was spinning with everything that had happened that night. Nolan sensed her thoughts had drifted and quickly caught her attention by pushing himself inside her, inch by excruciatingly thick inch. She sucked in a tight breath as the pain of being entered for the first time surprised her. Tears sprang to her eyes but she held back her whimper with a press of her lips. She gazed up at Nolan, focusing on his face as he slowly penetrated her with the single-minded focus of a man on a mission. God, he was breathtaking. She could stare at him all day. Suddenly, a sharp pain ripped through her as he made one final hard thrust against her. She screamed and clutched at Nolan as sweat broke out along her hairline. That must’ve been her hymen, she thought in a pained daze.