Olivia nodded, and together they went to go find their dad.
“Dad, can I talk to you?” Ivy said. She and her sister had finally found him in the kitchen, talking animatedly to Rafe, the coffin carpenter.
“Sure,” he said and smiled, gesturing for Ivy to say whatever was on her mind.
“In private?” Ivy clarified.
Her dad looked puzzled, but then he saw Olivia standing at Ivy’s side and noticed the looks on the girls’ faces, and his expression changed to one of concern. “Of course,” he said quickly and set his drink on the counter. “Pardon me, Rafe. Let us go up to my study,” he suggested to the girls.
The journey through the house and up the stairs to the second floor felt like it took an eternity to Ivy. Every few feet, someone stopped her father and wanted to chat. Finally, the three of them reached the study. Her father shut the door and went and sat in his office chair.
“Is everything all right?” he asked.
This is it, thought Ivy. “We know,” she said simply.
A series of reactions crossed her father’s face: shock, then panic, followed by denial. “You know what?” he said, then shrugged unconvincingly.
“We know you’re our father,” Olivia answered.
“And we know about our mom, too,” Ivy finished.
Her father stared at them in disbelief. “B-but how...” he stammered.
“We found your wedding photo,” Ivy explained.
“And the journal you kept,” added Olivia.
Their dad searched their faces, his eyes fluttering frantically from Ivy to her sister. Ivy could tell he was desperately trying to figure out what to say. For a second, a crooked smile revealed his teeth, and she knew he was tempted to deny everything. But then the smile disappeared, and a pained look was all that remained.
“You know everything?” he whispered. Ivy and Olivia nodded, and their father closed his eyes. Suddenly he breathed in sharply, as if he had been punched in the stomach.
“I loved your mother so very much.” He was holding his breath, his voice high and strained. “I didn’t think I could live.” He swallowed. “The only thing that kept me in this world...was the two of you.” All at once, he slumped in his chair and tears streamed from his eyes. He put his face in his hands and wept.
Ivy felt like she was watching her own father be reduced to dust. It was awful. She and Olivia reached out, but he raised his hands, gesturing for them to stay back so he could go on.
“My parents always told me that vampires and humans shouldn’t mix,” he explained. “But the moment I met Susannah, your mother, I knew at once she was the only woman for me. I didn’t care that she was human.” He roughly wiped the tears from his eyes with the palms of his hands. “When she told me she was pregnant, I thought it was a miracle. I had believed—everyone believed—that that just wasn’t possible. I thought it was proof of the extraordinary power of our love.” He shook his head forlornly. “I could not have been more wrong.”
“She died in labor?” Olivia said.
“She died,” her father answered soberly, “because of me. I never should have let her love me. My parents were right—vampires and humans should not mix. It only brings tragedy.”
He leveled his eyes at Ivy. “You see now, my darling, why we must move?”
“But the Vampire Round Table—” Olivia began.
“My dear Olivia, my beautiful daughter,” he interrupted, turning his hopeless eyes on her. “Yes, the Vampire Round Table accepts you. But that does not make you one of us. I could not believe it when I learned you had come to Franklin Grove. It was certainly destiny for you and Ivy to find each other.” He sighed. “I suppose, somewhere deep inside, I wanted it to happen. I left you both our rings. But I could not bear to lose you the way I lost Susannah,” he said hoarsely. “That is why we must be apart.” He rapped the desk with his fist, like a judge decreeing his decision.
Ivy wanted to say something to convince her father that everything would be okay. Except now she wasn’t so sure herself. What if something horrible does happen to Olivia if we stay together? she thought. After all, it was my embryo’s blood that infected our mom. Olivia’s hand slipped from her own, and the three of them were silent, lost in their own thoughts.
Then their father turned his chair away and gently asked them to leave him for a moment. Ivy and her sister walked slowly out of the room. There seemed to be nothing left to say.
Olivia and her sister sunk to the wooden floor in the hallway outside their father’s study.
“It wasn’t his fault,” Olivia said softly.
“You’re right,” Ivy said, a curtain of hair shielding her face. “It was mine.”
“What?” Olivia asked in surprise.
“You were the human baby,” Ivy explained sadly. “I was the vampire. Our mother died from having me.”
“Ivy, that’s not true,” Olivia protested. Her sister looked at her doubtfully out of the corner of her eye. “Brendan’s father said the human and vampire cells polarized. After that it would have been a normal pregnancy.”
Ivy shook her head. “We don’t know that.”
Our father spent the last thirteen years blaming himself for our mother’s death, Olivia thought. I can’t let Ivy make the same mistake. She stood up and held out her hand. “Come on.”
“Where are we going?” Ivy asked, allowing herself to be pulled to her feet.
“To find Mr. Daniels,” Olivia told her. “We’re going to get this straightened out once and for all.”